An Insider’s Guide to Color-Matching Repairs to an Old House

an old detached house with large front lawn
Featured Post

Step into the time-slip of restoring an old house, and you’ll find yourself playing a chromatic detective, hunting for clues in plasters and paints. It’s a puzzle where every hue whispers secrets from decades past.

Color-matching repairs to these historical canvases are akin to finding the perfect vintage thread for a heritage quilt — it’s delicate, precise work that’s as much art as it is science.

Color-Matching Your Home’s Exterior

a home with red sidings

Color-matching plays a crucial role in preserving the aesthetic integrity of an old house, as it ensures that any repairs or renovations blend seamlessly with the existing structure. Old houses often possess a unique charm, partly due to their distinct color schemes that reflect the architectural styles and periods in which they were built.

Proper color-matching respects and maintains these historical hues, ensuring that the character and heritage of the house are preserved.

Whether it’s repairing chipped paint or restoring faded areas, matching the original colors helps maintain the house’s overall appearance, ensuring that modern updates do not disrupt its historical ambiance and visual harmony.

Chasing Shadows: The Art of Modern Mimicry

an old home with white sidings

When it comes to blending the new with the old, especially in the case of replacement vinyl siding, you are tasked with capturing a moment in time. Imagine trying to insert a brand new puzzle piece into a well-worn set where the colors have softly faded; that’s your challenge.

New components may stand out like a clean penny in a handful of aged coins if not matched thoughtfully. So how do you coax modern materials to speak the language of yesteryears?

It starts by studying the existing palette with an eagle eye and understanding that sunlight and storms have been painting layers of history on what remains. Here’s a step-by-step overview of what’s involved:

1. Inspect the Original Color

Begin by examining the area during different times of the day. Morning light versus dusk can reveal subtle undertones in the paint that might otherwise be missed. Here’s how you can take accurate color samples from your house for matching:

  1. Identify the Original Color Areas: Find areas on your house where the original paint is still intact. This might be under eaves, behind downpipes, or in other areas protected from the elements.
  2. Clean the Sample Area: Gently clean the area where you’ll take the sample. This ensures that you get the true color, free from dirt or oxidation.
  3. Use a Sharp Blade: Carefully scrape off a small piece of paint with a sharp utility knife or blade. Aim for a sample size of at least a quarter-inch in diameter to get an accurate reading.
  4. Protect the Sample: Place the paint chip in a small plastic bag or an envelope to protect it. Label it with the location on the house where it was taken.
  5. Consider Multiple Samples: If the house has been painted multiple times, you might need samples from different layers to understand the historical color palette.

2. Historical Research

a victorian home with cream sidings

Delve into the archives. Search for old photographs, records, or any documents detailing original paint formulas or renovations to get a sense of the authentic colors.

Start by identifying the architectural style of your home. Different styles often have distinct color schemes. For example, Victorian homes tend to have more elaborate color schemes, while Craftsman-style homes usually feature earth tones.

Visit local historical societies, libraries, or preservation organizations. They can provide valuable information about regional architectural styles, popular color palettes of specific eras, and any historical records of your home.

3. Sample Card Comparison

Armed with sample cards from your local paint store, it’s time for a match-off! Place these against your siding in various lights to find the closest match.

Also, look into current color trends, and see if there’s a way to incorporate them with your repairs sympathetically, giving you the best of old and new.

4. Custom Mixing

If off-the-shelf paints don’t fit the bill, venture forth to professional mixologists — your local paint shop — who can tweak hues with precision. Make sure you take an accurate sample along for them to base their color-matching. A photo will never give the true color and you could end up with something in an entirely different tone!

You can employ a color-matching tool or a spectrophotometer, available at many paint stores, which can analyze the color of your sample and provide a custom mix. Remember, if the color has faded, it might affect the accuracy, so consider this when reviewing the match.

5. Patch Test Protocol

Before committing to a large quantity, purchase a small amount of the color-matching paint or siding and test it on a discreet area of your house to ensure it matches well in all lighting conditions.

Apply swatches directly onto your siding; then retreat a few steps. Squint a little—this isn’t just for dramatic effect—it helps blend the colors and better determine compatibility.

[mailerlite_form form_id=7]

6. Neighborly Consultation

Sometimes those living around you hold pieces of history in their memory. A quick chat may unearth insights into regional color trends and materials used over time.

Look at other old houses in your neighborhood, especially those built around the same time as yours. They might have retained their original color schemes, providing clues to historically accurate colors.

7. Finish with Finesse

a house with a mixture of grey sidings and stonework

Remember that sheen matters as much as shade! Match not just color but also finish – matte, eggshell, or anything in between! This is why getting a sample and testing it against the original paint, plaster or siding is extremely important before you make a decision.

8. Patina Perception

Pay attention to how age has altered the original color. A good match might require selecting a hue that’s slightly muted to mimic the effects of time.

Look for spots where the original color might have been shielded from sun and weather. This could be under eaves, behind downspouts, or beneath fixtures. The color in these areas is likely to be closer to the original color.

9. Lab Analysis Leverage

For a scientific approach, consider having paint scrapings analyzed by a conservation lab. They can often pinpoint historic pigments and offer modern equivalents.

Professionals specializing in historical preservation can provide expert advice on color schemes that are appropriate for the age and style of your home.

10. Digital Palette Assistance

Utilize technology with apps and tools designed for color matching. Snap a photo and let algorithms suggest the closest commercial paint options.

11. Weathered Wear Simulation

If installing new vinyl siding, look for artificially weathered samples to forecast how they’ll look after facing the elements alongside their older companions. Remember, due to fading and weathering, it may not always be possible to achieve an exact match.

12. Expert Emissaries

Don’t shy away from consulting restoration specialists. Their seasoned eyes and vast experience in period-appropriate materials can guide you through tricky matches with sage advice.

Many paint manufacturers and preservation societies publish guides to historical paint colors. These can offer insights into the colors that were popular during the period when your home was built.


By following these points with vim and rigor, your quest for the holy grail of hues will not only preserve but also honor the integrity of an older home’s character – one brush stroke at a time.

The last thing to mention is that you need to pay attention to any local building regulations and preservation rules that may apply to your older property during renovations. Don’t rush in, as you might end up having to undo all your hard work later on!

[mailerlite_form form_id=7]

An Insider's Guide to Color-Matching Repairs to an Old House Pinterest pin

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *